Every year in Madison Square Park, NYC restaurateur, Danny Meyer brings together some of the best pit masters from restaurants around the country for an extraordinary block party that gives you the chance to sample some of the best BBQ available in the USA. This year I was sure to get there early and with a fast pass – which gives you access to a short VIP line instead of waiting on a line that wraps around the block.
There were some pit masters that left me finger licking and wanting more while others fell a bit short. Each plate was sold for $8 a pop and I rated each each one with a 5 star system.
MoonLite Bar-B-Q Inn from Owensboro, KY served mutton sandwiches and burgoo (like a stew/chilli). This was the first time I’ve ever had mutton, which is the meat from an older sheep. I found these sandwiches to be tasty but over salted. The burgoo was really yummy and a big bowl of that would make me very happy on a cold winter day. Overall I gave the MoonLite 3 stars.
Next I made it over to Pappy’s Smokehouse from St. Louis, MO. They served ribs and baked beans. Pappy’s ribs were sweet, smokey and just delicious. I am usually not a big fan of baked beans but these were out of this world and I ate the whole serving. Pappy’s plate earned 5 stars!
NYC’s own Blue Smoke served up gigantic Texas style salt and pepper beef ribs. Tasty and tendy but very fatty. Blue Smoke did not blow me away and I gave them 3 stars.
Black Jack BBQ from Charleston, SC had me the most disappointed. Their pulled pork sandwiches were had a great vinegary taste but were extremely too dry to bother eating. Although the cole slaw was delish I didn’t finish this plate of food (I didnt want to “waste” the space in my stomach). Black Jack’s certainly fell far from 21 and I only gave them 2 stars.
Jim ‘n Nick’s Bar -B-Q from Birmingham, AL served up something a bit different that totally blew my mind. Homemade smoked sausage with pimento cheese. The sausage was spicy and when eaten with the pimento cheddar cheese it delivered a huge bite of flavor that knocked my socks from here to Alabama! I enjoyed this food the most and gave them 5 stars!


This must be either Jim or Nick grilling up some spicy sausages.
I finished up the day with a few St. Louis Style ribs from the Checkered Pig from Martinsville, VA. These ribs has that St. Louis flavor that I love so much but were a bit too fatty for me. Their slaw however, was spicy and refreshing. So I had to give them 3 1/2 stars.
There were 12 other restaurants represented at the BBQ that I did not get to sample. I left Madison Square Park with a VERY full stomach and a great appreciation for the wonderful flavors that our country has to offer.
Stuffing your face at the Big Apple BBQ makes for a great day. You never know what you’ll taste or see.
I sure wasn’t expecting this…..

Before...After!